Ask HN: How can I get good at piano?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6802255

by bjarn_kerfluup • 13 years ago

8 9 13 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

In regards to this post, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6791742, I am wondering if someone knows of articles that provide a similar type of system, but in the context of playing piano. Both piano and chess are highly intellectual activities, and help build neurons which in turn make us better programmers since we are able to think in new ways.

ScottWhigham• 13 years ago

I think the primary difference here is going to be muscle memory. Both require creativity (to varying degrees, of course) but piano requires physical, hands-on rote work rather than purely intellectual study. There's value in "the study of music" away from the instrument but there is no substitute for hours spent practicing, playing, and performing. He talks about "practice" - practice playing chess is often against a computer or a previously played match's moves. Practice on the piano though involves you playing exercises, pieces, and or just playing around.

The other difference is the definition of "good". There is no 90% in piano - you won't "win" at piano. You don't get "points" for playing a recital and there is no "#1 in the world". So I think "good" is relative when it comes to music/art whereas it's a concrete for sport/game. You might think "good" is "Playing along with my favorite recording" while I might rate "good" as "Able to play Chopin's hardest pieces".

rasterbate• 13 years ago

While sort of plodding and very rote, I know many teachers start with the Suzuki method, at least for a novice student. The method takes the form of a series of volumes, with the level of difficulty increasing with each volume. Not only does this allow you to self-select a starting point based on your existing skill level (if any), it also gives you a large library of material calibrated to be the right degree of challenging for your current level of skill. The first volume is very easy, so even a total beginner could likely work through the excises, and it's great for autodidacts, since the booklets explain the material and theory very thoroughly.

Patrick_Devine• 13 years ago

I'm in my late 30's and have been teaching myself how to play the piano for the past year and a half. I started off by buying an electric piano (a Yamaha P-155) and some Super Mario Bros. sheet music. My reasoning was I know all of the songs and Konji Kondo's work got more complex when he was composing for progressively more capable consoles.

I absolutely sucked donkeys at first. Even the 8-bit Super Mario theme song is pretty difficult when you're trying to read sheet music for the first time. It was pretty embarrassing, but I've stuck with it and try to play for at least 20-30 minutes a day. I also try to play on any piano I can find, and also try to play for anyone who will listen, just so that I get practice playing in front of people. That was actually remarkably difficult at first; my hands were literally shaking as I tried to plonk out a song. But, it's like anything. If you keep doing it you get better and better.

Here's the link to the sheet music: http://www.amazon.com/Super-Mario-Series-Piano-Easy/dp/07390...

cprncus• 13 years ago

I would think having a great piano teacher would be key (pardon the pun). S/he is a coach, a motivator, someone who knows how to spot and correct your form (which is critical), knows which pieces are useful as studies at which points in your development, can help guide you through theory, etc. What's not to love?

A kindly woman in her late 50s with glasses that are attached with decorative chains that loop around her neck is preferable.

raarts• 13 years ago

Buy a good piano, get a great teacher, and practice. A lot!

staunch• 13 years ago

Take lessons at the local city college.

bjourne• 13 years ago

Invest in a good piano teacher. It is very expensive, but I can almost guarantee that you will progress many times faster than if you try to learn it all by yourself.

zachlatta• 13 years ago

In addition to what other commentors have suggested, I highly recommend giving something like https://giveit100.com/ a try. I saw the founders at Startup School and their product definitely has very real potential.

I've personally had tremendous success committing to work on something every day.

malandrew• 13 years ago

Has anyone produced a keyboard with piano action keys that works like the gTar does?

Seems like something like that should exist.

http://www.incidentgtar.com/

Ask HN: How can I get good at piano?

Related Stories