Ask HN: Examples of beautifully designed php applications

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=679997
by apsurd • 17 years ago
4 5 17 years ago

Can anyone recommend a great example of beautifully/elegantly designed php application.

Disclaimer:

I can't comprehend how wordpress, joomla, drupal, xoops, or oscommerce can be considered good code. Mainly because they don't employ MVC and I love MVC.

Why MVC?

I think it makes an application dead simple and beautifully elegant. One of the biggest reasons being clean and descriptive urls. MVC essentially turns the browser bar into a command line.

## www.mysite.com/store/cart/show_items

I love the clarity you get from being able to access methods from a controller in such a ridiculously clean way. This also eliminates dirty/cryptic urls. Why are "clean urls" still an option?

Then there's "include/require". MVC (Kohana) elimites includes from your app logic. Wheras non mvc projects (like the ones mentioned above) have include/require absolutely plastered throughout every function of their code. Needless to say it makes reading source impossible.

It's impossible (for me at least) to guage the scope and bearings within a non-MVC system.

Am I alone on this? Is there something I'm missing? Are there pros to NOT using MVC? I learned coding through learning kohana/MVC so it's all I know. But I'm ready to learn so I am looking forward to great examples of well designed applications, MVC or not, thanks!

Related Stories

Loading related stories...

Source preview

news.ycombinator.com