A question on public/private key encryption

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6294654

by aa0 • 13 years ago

1 4 13 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

Why can't the private key be cracked by encrypting a large enough block of static data, all bits=1 for example, with the public key?

deanfranks2• 13 years ago

If the cypher being used is secure, encrypting a block of 1s or 0s will generate an apparently random stream of 0s and 1s. There will be no way to determine the private key from the output of encrypting a block of known data with the public key.

aa02• 13 years ago

Couldn't a cross-comparison be used, encrypting different known blocks and observing certain key properties? I would imagine that any kind of reversible operation would be able to be deduced if it can be applied to specific data that reveals its true form/operation.

deanfranks2• 13 years ago

Not with a strong cypher. Any single bit change in the source will result in what looks like a new pseudo-random output.

Determining the private key given the public key in RSA-2048 requires factorizing large blocks of very large numbers which is not practical given current computing hardware. People are working on "smart" attacks that solve the factorization problem from a theoretical math angle instead of a brute force computational approach and there is some consensus that RSA-2048 may be broken in the next few years. A transition to Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC) is underway and RSA has never been approved for Suite-A or Suite-B encryption which might lead one to believe that the NSA has known about the weakness of RSA for a long time.

A question on public/private key encryption

Related Stories