The App Store Hype Gets A Dose Of Reality

http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/05/25/the-app-store-hype-gets-a-dose-of-reality/?awesm=tcrn.ch_2Y1&utm_campaign=techcrunch&utm_content=techcrunch-autopost&utm_medium=tcrn.ch-twitter&utm_source=direct-tcrn.ch

by peter123 • 17 years ago

17 12 17 years ago

techcrunch.com

bcl• 17 years ago

Duh? Any developer knows that the success of their app is a crap shoot. We don't need techcrunch to tell us the bloody obvious.

jfarmer• 17 years ago

I'm going to toot my own horn an link to an article I wrote six months ago: http://20bits.com/articles/the-099-app-store/

It's the same fundamental misunderstanding. It's like launching a Facebook app and hoping the app directory helps you take off (in the early days there were people who did just this), or banking on getting mentioned on TechCrunch.

Now, I don't know what Rick Strom did or didn't do to market his apps, but success or failure isn't the App Store's fault. It removes a huge chunk of friction from the sales funnel, but it's all at the final, transactional step.

There's a big chunk in the middle which consists of marketing and, AFAIK, no app developer has talked extensively about their marketing efforts, only about their position in the App Store.

Rick is right: you're probably going to lose that game. Rather than go home I'd try to figure out a better game to play.

patio11• 17 years ago

Rather than go home I'd try to figure out a better game to play.

Downloadable software where the main source of app discovery is Google rather than the App Store? (i.e. for Macs or PCs or both)

App Store: 600,000 competitors, success by any of which decreases your visibility.

Whole wide Internet: lots of other people writing software, but if they're not in your niche they might as well not exist. I don't lose sales just because DeliciousMonster launched.

App Store: sales curve starts with initial spike, then dies within 2 weeks.

Whole wide Internet: sales curve typically gradually increases as you tune your site and marketing with step increases at new releases

App Store: iFart

Whole wide Internet: you make apps people use on a daily basis for things that are important to them. They send you letters about how happy your app made them.

App Store: $4.99 is expensive

Whole wide Internet: $19.99 is cheap

mighty• 17 years ago

I think there's a lot Apple needs to do to improve the IA of the App Store, and they need to make the iTunes store accessible from standard web browsers rather than just the iTunes software. But there's nothing preventing iPhone app developers from creating websites for their apps, and there are a variety of sites that review apps. That you cannot buy an iPhone app outside of the App Store does nothing to prevent developers from gaining visibility outside of it. There is nothing preventing anyone from Googling for iPhone apps (just as you can Google for non-iPhone apps), than the developers themselves.

As for the differences in sales curves, that's actually reflective of how much easier it is to find and purchase new apps on the App Store (as well as the increased competition -> price reduction that their aggregation provides), as opposed to having hundreds or thousands of different purchase sites with their own method for payment processing. Also note that most iPhone apps tend to be for entertainment, for which an early sales spike and sudden drop-off is the norm regardless of platform...or medium.

jsz0• 17 years ago

It seems to me this is just one big made up story. I seem to recall TechCrunch was one of the sites reporting these hyped up stories of someone successfully quitting their job to develop iPhone apps or a teenager making $20K a week. Now they're telling us not to believe the hype they helped create? Seems they're milking this thing for all its worth.

zimbabwe• 17 years ago

In Drew Curtis's book It's Not News, It's Fark, he talks about how more than anything, the media loves talking about media, because they understand it the most. That means any huge story almost inevitably turns into reports of "Has the media gone too far?" and "What role do we have in stories' getting out of hand?"

I see no reason why this wouldn't apply to mass-market tech blogs.

mattmaroon• 17 years ago

"Strom likens the App Store to a lottery, with the time and cost spent developing your application as the price of admission. And I think he’s right in this respect. The thing is, I don’t really see how this differs from many professions where the rich and elite are given heavy media coverage while everyone else toils away in obscurity."

Maybe not, but it's a lot different than developing for the web or Facebook, where you can continuously iterate on your product, get better over time, attract a few loyal users and expand from there. The difference between iPhone and other software platforms is like the difference between trying to become a pop star or starting a software company.

TweedHeads• 17 years ago

The AppStore has become such a successful magnet for developers that it is being attacked from every front just to push them away from the ecosystem.

They are afraid Objective-C and XCode become the next development platform.

Well you know what? With all its defects, it is still the number one marketplace for online apps. And Objective-C, a complete unknown a couple of years ago, is hotter than never.

Period.

sgrove• 17 years ago

Who is attacking the AppStore?

Who is afraid Objective-C and Xcode will be the next development platform?

What does "the next development platform" even mean?

ObjC and Xcode are just fine, and developing apps for the iPhone is a lot of fun (outside of the AppStore experience, apparently), but I'm not sure they deserve any sort of conspiracy theory.

quantumhobbit• 17 years ago

"To those of you who keep building things anyway: rock on."

I think that for developers and pretty much anyone in a creative pursuit the above mentality is key. If you set out to build something solely for the money you are not going to produce something of the same quality as someone who builds something they want to build anyway, and consequently you will fail at your objective.

cubicle67• 17 years ago

I keep reading all these stories about how bad the App Store is, and how you can't sell stuff after the first few days. I've got one app up there that took me a day to write, is typical of the 'this is my first iPhone app' apps, hasn't been updated in about 5 months (and thus would be well towards the back of the pack) and yet still sells a moderate number of copies each month.

trillablue• 17 years ago

Inevitably every dev that comments for an article on how the App Store is flawed/overhyped falls into one of two categories:

1. Those that relied on merely having their app in the app store to generate purchases. 2. Those that spent far too long and far too much developing an app then fell into trap #1.

The App Store Hype Gets A Dose Of Reality

Related Stories