Show HN: ParcelKit integrates Core Data with Dropbox Datastore API

https://github.com/overcommitted/ParcelKit

by daniel_levine • 13 years ago

11 7 13 years ago

github.com

kennywinker• 13 years ago

Very cool!

Is this in active use in an app yet? Would you describe it as "production ready" or more "experimental" or "beta"?

Will definitely be looking at this for an upcoming project.

pbsdp2• 13 years ago

It's not possible to seamlessly/transparently/asynchronously synchronize data; conflict resolution must be done.

If this was possible, iCloud+CoreData would have worked, and Oracle/PostgreSQL/etc would be shipping transparent, ACID, horizontally scalable RDMS.

LinaLauneBaer• 13 years ago

From what I have seen this project uses the Dropbox Datastore API. The Dropbox Datastore API has very limited support for conflict resolution:

- DBResolutionRemote: The remote value will be chosen. This is the default behavior for all fields.

- DBResolutionLocal: The local value of the field will be chosen.

- DBResolutionMax: The greater of the two changes will be chosen.

- DBResolutionMin: The lesser of the two changes will be chosen.

- DBResolutionSum: Additions and subtractions to the value will be preserved and combined.

So with these limited conflict resolution options conflicts might occur but they can be resolved automatically. I am not saying this is good or bad but beside setting one of those resolution modes there is nothing else to do - except explaining to users what happened to their data in the case of a conflict that should have been resolved with a more sophisticated mechanism.

iCloud+Core Data on the other hand allows custom conflict resolution on the clients.

smarx• 13 years ago

We're definitely looking at adding more options for custom conflict resolution once we get out of beta.

pbsdp2• 13 years ago

iCloud+Core Data on the other hand allows custom conflict resolution on the clients.

The new APIs in iOS 7 do, but then you lose all the value of "transparent distributed store" and it winds up being a pretty sizable hassle.

seivan• 13 years ago

I never felt it was a good idea to integrate context/memory, persistent store and networking into a single library. I've gotten burned with that.

The whole concept of integrating business objects with some RESTful API that is supposedly going to be soooo perfect that everything just works is funny, you're always going to run into trouble and wish things were separated so it would be easier to work with the API.

malandrew• 13 years ago

Completely agree. However I'd like to hear what solutions out there you have used that do a good job of fully encapsulating each of those roles (context/memory, persistent store and networking) and work together well out of the box or with simple adapters?

Show HN: ParcelKit integrates Core Data with Dropbox Datastore API

Related Stories