Do we really need javascript frameworks?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5951643

by Proleps • 13 years ago

8 8 13 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I started learning javascript and web development a while a go. I decided to learn javascript without any frameworks or libraries so I would properly learn the basics.

So far I haven't really felt the need to use frameworks or libraries. I've been close to using JQuery but I've able to avoid it until now. But even if I end up using JQuery, it is just a library and not a framework.

What do frameworks like Backbone.js, and ember.js have to offer? These frameworks offer functionality at the cost of adding a lot of complexity.

cyphax2• 13 years ago

I have asked myself that question over the last few years and I have come to the conclusion that I really want these frameworks. In the case of jQuery, for example: you can program everything in Javascript without using jQuery. On the other hand, jQuery is not just a lot of code, it's tested code. It's not much fun having to add browser/engine-specific code to everything you do. Thankfully, the need for this specifically seems to be slowly fading away now that all browsers are to a certain extend on the same level.

In the case of such frameworks like Backbone/ember/Angular: these are implementations of MVC or MVVM or other such patterns, in Javascript. These make it easy to share data between web services you create, and, in the case of e.g. Knockout, bind data to controls on your page. You save yourself from having to write AND test all these things yourself. I have tried, for the first time, Backbone mere days ago, to see what the added benefit is. It gave me what's required to send data (in JSON format) to, for example, my controller, but what's nice about it is, for example, model binding.

It might not be entirely unlike PHP's situation: you can program your projects in plain PHP, or you can use the Zend Framework or Symphony or whatever you prefer, which adds a lot of (tested) logic that you otherwise would have to program yourself.

Do you NEED it? Not using these won't limit you, but you'll probably find yourself programming these things out yourself in a lot of cases, where many smart people have done this already.

Proleps• 13 years ago

On the other hand, jQuery is not just a lot of code, it's tested code

I haven't really looked at it from that point of view, I guess that is a pretty a pretty big advantage. The basics of writing a widget are pretty simple most of the time, but testing it on different browsers and edge cases always takes more time than I think it will.

cyphax2• 13 years ago

Before I started using jQuery, I hadn't thought of it that way either. But after seeing that something that would normally take me days to program (in a way that it'd work in IE7, for example) only took me hours in jQuery, and finding that, indeed, it worked in all major browsers right away, I thought of it that way since! :)

meerita• 13 years ago

Same question I did myself with HTML/CSS. Do we need those frameworks to do a website?

The question came to me after I did my 3rd bootstrap like architecture for some projects I've been working for. You will end doing something like JQuery in the end, if you want to be organized and want to maintain all in a large team, you end up doing a framework so everyone does the same.

After doing it 4 times, I realized I can use Boostrap and do the same on 1/4 of the requiered time and, avoid the testing phase for many, many things.

CyberFonic• 13 years ago

No! You don't need them. But ... you'll save yourself lots of time by reusing tried and tested code instead of writing everything from scratch and having to debug all the edge cases and behaviours on different browsers.

workhere-io• 13 years ago

Whether or not you need a framework like AngularJS depends on your website. If it's just a normal website there's no reason to use a framework. But if it's more like an app, say a calendar where you can add/edit/delete items without reloading the page, then AngularJS and similar frameworks come in handy.

hkarthik• 13 years ago

Aside from functionality and complexity, frameworks can offer consistency and reliability. The latter two are very important when trying to create large applications rapidly with larger teams.

chc• 13 years ago

If you feel like Backbone adds a lot of complexity, your project is not yet big enough to need it. For projects that need Backbone, it actually removes complexity by helping to enforce structure. Organizational tools always seem pointless until you have a lot of stuff to organize.

Do we really need javascript frameworks?

Related Stories