A successful Git branching model

http://nvie.com/posts/a-successful-git-branching-model#

by atmb4u • 13 years ago

8 3 13 years ago

Aga• 13 years ago

One thing the article unfortunately fails to mention is the motivation for this model. A branching model, as any other policy or technical solution, should be an answer to an existing problem. So decoupling the branching model from projects details makes no sense to me, although the article does a fair job describing the technical aspects.

I've been asked many times by units (big corporation) if this would be a good branching model for them when they are migrating to Git. I always tell them it's probably too complicated for their situation. Most of the units are trying to implement some form of Continuous Integration. Obfuscating that with complex branching models would only confuse them. Only when they encounter a real problem, that could be solved with this branching model, I suggest they try this out. I haven't still seen it happen.

However I must say, that the situation might be different in different types of projects. I've seen only these kind of CI-projects with a couple of hundreds developers with long lead times.

qohen• 13 years ago

Github found git-flow wasn't suitable given that they do CI and developed their own method of using git, Github Flow: http://scottchacon.com/2011/08/31/github-flow.html

A different article on a CI-based approach, with comparison to git-flow: http://nxvl.blogspot.com/2012/07/a-continous-delivery-git-br...

dsego• 13 years ago

This is an older article from 2010. The author later created the git extension named git-flow based on this model - https://github.com/nvie/gitflow

A successful Git branching model

Related Stories