Billy Beane got it right

https://toddmoses.beehiiv.com/p/billy-beane-got-it-right

by mtmosestn • 1 month ago

3 2 1 month ago

toddmoses.beehiiv.com

mtmosestn• 1 month ago

The subject of Money Ball figured out what everyone else could not see.

k310• 1 month ago

He figured out how to field a team on the cheap. The team (location varies) has the (second) lowest payroll of all teams, [0] It has a very wealthy owner, though not in the top ten. Billy Beane owns a piece of the team.

The team is not competitive at all. As soon as a rookie contract comes up for arbitration, the player is traded away. Salary = bad. So it is effectively a farm team for the entire league.

Since the owner couldn't get a giant real estate deal from Alameda County, they packed up their bags and are begging Las Vegas to create that John Fisher [1] real estate empire at Las Vegas' public expense. Las Vegas did so for the Raiders. Without a domed stadium, games have to be played at night, due to searing heat (dome considered too expensive) so the team now plays in the SF Giants' farm team field in Sacramento, which is NOT a major league ball park.

Las Vegas may reject welfare for Mr. Fisher.

The team collects welfare in the form of payments from MLB's "competitive balance tax" [2] and puts none of it into player salaries. It's just a money machine disguised as a baseball team, though they do have occasional moments of success when the soon to be traded young players show their stuff.

The team was legitimate and won world series when the Haas family [3] ran it. Heirs to the Levi-Strauss business, U.C. Berkeley Haas School of Business is named for them.

No praise for a cheapskate operation. Since HN does not allow edits, correct anything I got wrong.

Opinion stands.

[0] https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/mlb/2025/04/02/2025-ml...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Fisher_(businessman)

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_League_Baseball_luxury_t...

[3] https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/THE-HAAS-LEGACY-How-o...

Billy Beane got it right

Related Stories