Ask HN: Why hasn't someone built a decentralized compute network?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47997262

8 7 3 months ago

news.ycombinator.com

collyw• 3 months ago

Look up grid computing. It never really took off.

absynth• 3 months ago

really? I mean there's this little book company called Amazon who will let you use their interweb computers for a few dollars per hour. They'll sell you coffee as well.

jdw64• 3 months ago

There are decentralized systems out there, like torrents, but they are just too inconvenient. That's why they end up being used mostly for illegal sharing or niche academic stuff. Even Bitcoin is a great example. It was supposed to be completely decentralized, but if you look at reality, it's just been absorbed into centralized systems like big exchanges and mining pools

andrewfromx• 3 months ago

decentralized is a funny thing. people often say they want decentralized and say that’ll be great! No one person/company in charge. But is that what people want? Usually they want some kind of benevolent dictator instead.

mackwell• 3 months ago

They have, it’s just difficult to have it catch on. Bitcoin being the prime example… but the compute is basically burned for no useful purpose beyond security of the network itself. Because that is the main concern - security of the blockchain. Many have tried to use that same shape and instead have the compute be directed at something useful, with varying levels of success but nothing at that scale. There are however very successful long running projects like folding@home or the Mersenne prime search which have lots of people running a program locally that directs idle compute power on volunteers PCs to work on scientific pursuits.

There’s lots of cool examples of interesting things people have tried, (training models, etc) but it’s not easy to get traction.

Something like vast.ai is much easier to make fly because people who offer their resources for rent get directly paid by time used.

In short, it’s a cool idea that lots of people want but it’s hard to make fly.

Edit: also I guess we could consider malware / botnets successful implementations as well - for nefarious purposes.

sds357• 3 months ago

You mean the internet?

freakynit• 3 months ago

We have chutes.ai for distributed GPU computing and it seems to be quite successful.

https://chutes.ai/platform

Tokens processed through OpenRouter gateway: https://openrouter.ai/provider/chutes

Ask HN: Why hasn't someone built a decentralized compute network?

Related Stories