Against SemVer

https://www.natemeyvis.com/against-semver/

by Theaetetus • 7 months ago

2 3 7 months ago

natemeyvis.com

turtleyacht• 7 months ago

Author does not present an alternative, but one seen is based on timestamp, like version 2025.12.23.

Theaetetus• 7 months ago

Some alternatives:

- Finger to the wind ("this feels like a big change"). - Domain-specific versioning scheme (so Ruff uses [this variant](https://docs.astral.sh/ruff/versioning/#version-changes) that seems reasonable to me; it's described as a SemVer variant, but the work to specify how various cases are handled seems very useful to me). - As you say, time stamps. FWIW I don't like that very much, because time is often so weakly correlated with progress / "breakingness," but it has its proponents.

brudgers• 7 months ago

Semantic versioning encourages breaking changes through basic bigger-number-better human psychology...you can't get to version 10 without a lot of breaking changes.

And breaking changes are bad software engineering. That's what is bad about semantic versioning.

Against SemVer

Related Stories