Ask HN: What would I gain from using Rails over Codeigniter?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4460837

by therustytracks • 14 years ago

8 14 14 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I have a few ideas I've been kicking around for a while and I'm having trouble deciding on backend technologies. The backend is going to need to handle authentication/registration, CRUD using mongodb, and have a restful architecture. Most of my experience lies in PHP and Codeigniter. I'd like to know if it's worth it to learn Ruby and Rails. If so, what benefits would I gain using Rails over Codeigniter?

therustytracks6• 14 years ago

I've noticed over the past few weeks when I've been doing my research a lot of large scale applications use RoR. I haven't been able to find any applications that were built on Codeigniter that come close to the robustness of the apps using rails.

e12e• 14 years ago

I think part of that is that CodeIgniter has much less exposure and mind-share than rails does.

Personally I've given up on php because they keep having horrible problems with the core (c) code in the stack (not all of which are unique to php, like image processing libraries) -- but I don't think it fair to write off CodeIgniter as an alternative in general.

For anyone looking for a semi-large code-base using CI, I recommend having a look at Bamboo Invoice:

http://bambooinvoice.org/

That said I would have been very happy to see more of Expression Engine published under an open licence as well:

http://expressionengine.com/

My impression is that some of the projects that might have built larger stacks on top of CI just go (or went) with EE rather than write the code themselves.

therustytracks6• 14 years ago

Codeigniter was the first php framework I learned. It was really easy to understand and extend. However it just doesn't feel right and I'm starting to think I'm just tired of php. I've seen bamboo invoice before. There are a few other robust projects I've seen but nothing that you could compare to 37signals apps or github.

1123581321• 14 years ago

We use both Rails and CodeIgniter. Rails has a much more useful core and its libraries are more robust and useful. That means you will be able to develop more quickly. However, you will have to spend some time learning how it works if you've no experience, and you will want to build your app the Rails way which might mean some redesign (hopefully not too much.)

Here's what you should look into: auth: devise gem, crud: Rails defaults + mongoid gem, rest: by default in Rails.

therustytracks6• 14 years ago

Awesome. I've been looking for a reason to start learning rails. I took a look at devise when I was doing some research it looks awesome. Gems are so sweet. Codeigniter has a package management system (sparks) but the modules aren't that great or maintained. Thanks for your advice I'll definitely be looking into Rails and the gems you mentioned.

cheald• 14 years ago

I like MongoMapper over Mongoid, personally; Mongoid seems to have breaking changes even between minor versions.

decadentcactus• 14 years ago

I started with CI like you, and have recently move to Django/Python. I feel as if Django completely blows CI out of the water when it comes to robustness, community, features, extendability etc (and I'd assume Rails is the same). Although I also probably just like Python better.

I'd say if it's a side project/more wishful success, go with Rails. At the very least, you'll learn something new and improve your skills. If it's something that absolutely needs to work now and is a bit more complex, use your existing CI knowledge for now.

But at some point (perhaps now) I'd just bite the bullet and go with Rails (or Django of course, but either would be a step up).

therustytracks6• 14 years ago

I definitely think I'm going to go for Rails. I've heard a lot of great things about Django as well. One of my coworkers swears by it. Thanks for the advice.

orangethirty2• 14 years ago

Is it worth learning? Depends. Do you want to get gigs doing Rails? What attracts you to it?

What benefits over CI does RoR have?

Right now, none. You dont know Rails, but you know CI. The time it takes you to learn RoR and its use of "magic" might be better spent writing your application and testing if there is demand for it.

Sure, RoR has a lot of "reusable code", but you don't hknow the framework. And that will just kill your project.

Build your basic app with CI, and then translate it into something else. I wouldnt stray away from PHP if you are proficient with it. You may try other frameworks like Laravel, which is very nice and is more modern that CI. It is also dead-easy to work with. You might also want to check out Python/Flask or even Django, since they are a bit easier to work with than Rails. Im not saying they are better, so put your pitchforks back in the barnyard.

therustytracks6• 14 years ago

There's no rush or urgency to build the app I have in mind. It's going to be a learning experience. I'm just tired of using the same framework and php. I've been doing quite a bit of node.js at work and it's pretty sweet. I just want to branch out and try new languages / technologies. The app I have in mind will be using phantomjs, possibly backbone for the frontend, and it looks like I'll be learning RoR for the backend.

orangethirty2• 14 years ago

That changes everything. Go learn RoR then. It will be lots of fun. Boy, do I envy you! Rails is definitely a joyful ride. Just don't listen to much to the fanboys and their absurdly complicated solutions to simple problems. Good luck and keep me posted. I'd love to hear about your progress.

jamierumbelow• 14 years ago

Rails is a great, progressive framework and I've learnt a lot about programming in general by taking the time to familiarise myself and work with it. Rails makes it very easy to write thoughtful, elegant code. But that's not to say that it's impossible or even difficult to do with CodeIgniter.

You can extend CodeIgniter's core classes very easily to provide a lot of the same magic you'll find in Rails. There are a lot of ORMs similar to ActiveRecord available, and a great MongoDB library written by Alex Bilbie (https://github.com/alexbilbie/codeigniter-mongodb-library). I've created a popular open source library that enables you to autoload views into layouts like in Rails (https://github.com/jamierumbelow/codeigniter-base-controller).

You can implement RESTful URLs simply and efficiently by customising the routes.php file yourself, or by using a route generation engine such as Pigeon (https://github.com/jamierumbelow/pigeon). If you'd prefer a more "full-stack" REST solution, you could use Phil Sturgeon's heinously popular REST_Controller (https://github.com/philsturgeon/codeigniter-restserver/).

All the above links are drag-and-drop solutions and take moments to download, configure and understand.

You will learn a lot about a whole different kind of writing applications when you learn Rails. But the same is true for Python/Django, the same is true for functional programming languages such as Clojure and the same is true for Objective-C and the iPhone SDK.

CodeIgniter is incredibly flexible and that's probably exactly why you use it. Taking a bit of time to interact with the community and see what gems are out there will let you write much better CI code, and a lot of the time you'll find you don't need or want Rails.

DISCLAIMER: I have written a book about writing better and more Rails-y code with CodeIgniter called The CodeIgniter Handbook (https://efendibooks.com/codeigniter-handbook/vol-1).

Ask HN: What would I gain from using Rails over Codeigniter?

Related Stories