Ask HN: Is it fair if my employer pays me less if I don't have a degree?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4222236

by pauljf • 14 years ago

11 12 14 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I dropped out of college my second year to work at a startup. After a few months, I was offered a full time position. When I was negotiating my salary the main reason my pay was stunted is because I don't have a college degree. I know my contribution to the project is no less than the other devs. Is this something common?

ricardobeat• 14 years ago

It's common to have pay bumped up a little for having a degree/masters. Why did they mention a higher salary before negotiation?

pauljf• 14 years ago

I actually found out in hindsight that someone who I work with has about 15% more pay than me because of having a degree, they had less work experience than me.

JudS• 14 years ago

They likely feel that they are taking a bit of a risk to hire you. If your performance is as good or better than others, then you can expect that your pay will increase to match theirs over time. Longer-term it has to be about performance, not what degree you hold.

notbitter• 14 years ago

They are bullshitting you. Big companies can have rigid salary structures, but at a startup you have lower pay because that's what you accepted. The degree argument is a negotiating tactic to get you to accept lower pay.

That said, if you don't get a degree you will likely be fighting this battle over and over for the rest of your working life. And college is a lot more fun when you're the same age as your classmates.

codeonfire• 14 years ago

Degrees make it much easier to get a job somewhere else, so companies have to pay competitively to keep that from happening. Its not about reward for having a degree or for contributions made, it's just economics. If you create extra profits through very hard work, the company will gladly take those and hand them over to the equity holders for you so they can buy a new car or whatever (thanks).

samstave• 14 years ago

That escalated quickly.

True though, there is only one person that will watch out for your best interests. Hint: it is never your employer.

michaelpinto• 14 years ago

Yes.

And I'll add something to that: When you become a fortysomething if you hit a down cycle and don't have a degree it can become a real dead end. Of course this isn't to say that having a degree is some sort of "magic get a job card", but when you get a certain age just having a high school degree isn't that great.

Lastly: I use to assume that the above assumption might have exceptions in the world of tech, but for example if you try to get a job at a place at Google not only do they want to know your degree, not only do you have to have killer grades — but they'll even go a step further and make you dig up your SAT scores!

So do yourself a favor: Get a degree while you're still young.

glimcat• 14 years ago

Negotiation is negotiation. You get what you can convince the other party to agree to.

israelyc• 14 years ago

Agreed, and since the other comments are also right about the value of a degree. Tell them that if you won't get the salary you want you will go back to school. Its a win win for you (and you should follow through)..

pdenya• 14 years ago

I haven't had any issues without a degree in terms of salary. It's "degree or relevant experience" everywhere. If this is your first or second job after dropping out of college, expect to get paid slightly less because you're a higher risk but once your proven a bit you shouldn't have this issue.

diminium• 14 years ago

It's all about leverage. The question is, do you need them more then they need you (and they know it)?

If yes, then your in trouble. If no, then they are in trouble.

lelele• 14 years ago

Yes, it is common because too many people drink the kool-aid. You should be entitled to be paid according to your contribution. "Should" because other factors may be involved: - paying you more might upset some employees with a degree; - paying you more might arise requests from some employees without a degree; - why pay you more when you are contented with less money? If your contributions overcome such side-effects, you can ask for more.

Ask HN: Is it fair if my employer pays me less if I don't have a degree?

Related Stories