Researchers say mankind is to blame for The Little Ice Age, too

http://www.investors.com/editorial/editorialcontent.asp?secid=1501&status=article&id=315533893763712

by gibsonf1 • 18 years ago

17 11 18 years ago

qqq2• 18 years ago

And mankind is to blame for traffic. I hate getting stuck in traffic!

eipiman• 18 years ago

The claim that "mankind" was responsible for the Little Age ignores the fact that one particular man, George Bush, was responsible. Now you know.

cpr• 18 years ago

Doesn't this ring false to any reasonable reader?

When the "white man" came to North America, at least by all accounts I've read, it was nearly entirely virgin forest (the old "a squirrel could travel from the Mississippi to the Atlantic without touching ground" chestnut). So where was this mass deforestation?

gojomo• 18 years ago

More recent scholarship suggests the Americas, before the arrival of european plagues, were far more densely populated, and the environment more shaped by native agriculture, than you might expect. A good summary of the ideas is Charles C. Mann's article "1491":

http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200203/mann

One estimate is that in the first 130 years of contact, 95% of a prior American population of over 100 million died.

Those 130 years happen to be about the first half of the 'little ice age', and the natives often used large-scale burns to clear and prepare land. So while IBD mocks the idea that the depopulation of the Americas caused the little ice age, it's at least plausible.

yummyfajitas• 18 years ago

That article appears to be a shorter version of his book. The book is well worth the $10.85 you'll spend on it.

http://www.amazon.com/1491-Revelations-Americas-Before-Colum...

newt0311• 18 years ago

Umm... temperatures dropped with no lead time? Most feedback systems (especially on a global scale) do not work nearly that quickly due to negative feedback. The idea that man caused the little ice age is ludicrous.

lionheart• 18 years ago

Why is stuff like is on Hacker News?

I come here to get away from the pointless arguments about stuff like global warming.

msie• 18 years ago

Because people like gibsonf1 won't stop posting them here.

qqq2• 18 years ago

Well don't blame him so much, 8 people upvoted it so far.

pg• 18 years ago

It would be interesting to read an article that actually analyzed this research. This one is basically a digg/reddit comment macroexpanded into the form of a newspaper editorial.

Allocator2008• 18 years ago

I thought I read someplace that sun spots had to do with the 1600's mini-ice age? Tying the fall of for example the Mayan civilization with the triggering of an ice age due to decrease in agricultural activity and associated re-forestation seems like a stretch.

Researchers say mankind is to blame for The Little Ice Age, too

Related Stories