StructuredRAG: JSON Response Formatting with Large Language Models

by bobvanluijt • 2 years ago

38 4 2 years ago

Interesting paper, but their reason for dismissing constrained decoding methods seems to be that they want to academically study the in-context setting.

For practitioners, using a framework like Guidance which forces the models to write valid JSON as they generate text solves this trivially (https://github.com/guidance-ai/guidance)

For json in particular these frameworks have functions that take in json schemas or pydantic schemas https://guidance.readthedocs.io/en/latest/generated/guidance...

myprotegeai• 2 years ago

And OpenAI also has Structured Outputs[1] that has the same effect as Guidance. I use it to safely deserialize remote function calls based on a jsonschema[2]. It works very well.

1. https://openai.com/index/introducing-structured-outputs-in-t... 2. https://github.com/amoffat/manifest

imtringued• 2 years ago

To be fair, they first build a benchmark which they call "StructuredRAG" and it doesn't make sense to run constrained decoding against a benchmark, because it would always get you a 100% success chance. Once they have a benchmark, they try to figure out whether it is possible to prompt engineer your way to a 100% success rate and by using ORPO to generate the prompt, they did achieve that 100% success rate without relying on constrained decoding.

l5870uoo9y• 2 years ago

It may additionally be promising to test Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting strategies. This entails adding a “rationale” key to the model’s output such that the additional reasoning improves the performance of the model. However, this will require the output to be a composite object with the additional "rationale" key and string-valued response. Our results suggest that this additional output structure may result in lower success rates. Similar in spirit to structured decoding methods, it may also be helpful to prefix the end of the prompt with “{“ or use the key, such as “{“paraphrased_questions”: [".

For most of my prompts I want CoT.

StructuredRAG: JSON Response Formatting with Large Language Models

Related Stories