Ask HN: How to help open sources improve their UX?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41317590

by aman-pro • 2 years ago

1 2 2 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I have some students I am teaching design. I want them to work on some real-world projects and not redesign interfaces without having a feedback loop telling how they did. I can't give them access to my client work.

Is there a way to find out open source projects that want someone to help with their User Experience?

solardev• 2 years ago

Can you just fork an open-source project of your choosing (or several) with a UI that you think could be improved, and assign that to your students?

That way they'd all be on equal footing anyway and can compare each other's designs.

Maybe at the end you can have students vote (or combine work, then polish it) and present it to the upstream author to see if they want to adopt it.

Otherwise, I think you'll end up spamming a lot of open-source projects (which are often already overwhelmed anyway) with student work of dubious quality, which the maintainers might not appreciate it. At least if you filter through their work first and only submit it upstream if it's good enough, you're playing the role of a curator and not just flooding projects with mediocre designs.

aman-pro• 2 years ago

This is a fair point. I would hate spamming any maintainer. Most of these contributions will happen after the students have completed their curriculum and done 1-2 concept designs. [Apologies if I did not make it clear that I am just trying to replace the redesign projects -- not the new concept design]

At the same time, if I fork any repo of my choice -- I don't think we'll necessary work on the most important aspects. Reducing the chances of the design getting incorporated or the students getting any objective feedback to improve things.

Ask HN: How to help open sources improve their UX?

Related Stories