Why do websites require "secret questions"?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4046109

by rangibaby • 14 years ago

1 3 14 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I wish Google (for example) would give me an option to provide no secret question.

They seem terribly insecure and an easy attack vector e.g. "What was your first phone number?" would be incredibly easy to coax out of a person simply by calling them and pretending to be from x phone company.

In the days of two-step verification, is making a security question compulsory obsolete?

antidoh• 14 years ago

You can simulate the option of no secret question, by giving an extremely wrong answer.

First phone number: Dwight Eisenhower.

epc• 14 years ago

There’s no reason to answer such questions with the “right” answer. My mother’s real maiden name is public information, so when asked for that I give a different memorable name.

About the only time I tell the truth on such forms is when it’s legally required (like a credit check form).

As far as two-step verification: of a sample set of my relatively savvy but not necessarily hardcore tech friends, only two are using two–step verification out of about 30 people. The others know about it but don’t get why they need it.

ott2• 14 years ago

The sensible treatment of a "secret question" is as a second password. Since it acts in parallel with the password, like a second door to your house, it should be at least as hard to guess as the "main" password.

I would go further than saying that this is obsolete: it is simply bad security design.

Why do websites require "secret questions"?

Related Stories