Will Stone Replace Concrete

https://www.construction-physics.com/p/will-stone-replace-steel-and-concrete

by andrewfurey2003 • 2 years ago

34 9 2 years ago

thbb123• 2 years ago

The analysis is interesting, but why the alternative of using bricks instead of stone or concrete is not studied at all?

Seems even more efficient to mould clay than to carve stones, even it becomes fully automated.

RicoElectrico• 2 years ago

The whole concept is based on local availability of stone, so probably that's the reason. Is clay similarly abundant?

citrin_ru2• 2 years ago

Firing bricks requires a lot of energy, cutting stone probably requires less energy but would be good to see the numbers.

kylehotchkiss• 2 years ago

Brick construction during an earthquake is an absolute nightmare. Steel tensioned stone sounds like it could potentially work around that?

31carmichael• 2 years ago

Bricks are not structural replacements for either concrete or stone.

mateo1• 2 years ago

Concrete is 15% cement and 85% stone. Just crushed, homogenous, predictable and structurally sound stone. You can't reinforce stone like you can reinforce concrete, and you can't pour stone. Stone will not replace concrete. As soon as the energy crisis ends, concrete prices will fall again. The requirements for stone to be used structurally are high, and I don't think production could ever match the demand that replacing concrete would create, or if it did, it would be a whole lot more expensive.

citrin_ru2• 2 years ago

You can compensate higher variability by building thicker walls than you would build with reinforced concrete (and it still may end up cheaper but it needs to be calculated).

You can't reinforce stone

Not every structure needs to be reinforced. Stone walls should be fine (at least in places with low seismic activity) and for floor slabs one can continue using reinforced concrete.

shzhdbi09gv8ioi• 2 years ago

We are running out of sand to make cement and concrete [1].

1: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2313170-we-are-running-...

thebeardisred• 2 years ago

I'm imagining the pit mining to retrieve the volume of large stones needed to keep up with concrete consumption.

Will Stone Replace Concrete

Related Stories