Everything Hikers Know About Lightning Safety Is Wrong

https://www.backpacker.com/survival/natural-hazards/lightning/lightning-safety-facts-for-hikers/

by Stratoscope • 2 years ago

20 6 2 years ago

aretafwe• 2 years ago

Sorry, but I hate this article just because of the stupid click-baity title. The author doesn't have half a clue what I already know.

kleiba• 2 years ago

I wouldn't say "hate" but in general I would have to agree. Besides the mildly contradictive list ("the lightning position" is bogus but "crouching" is recommended... er, isn't the lightning position kinda crouching?), I would say that all of the revelations of this article is exactly what I have been taught as a child... which was, cough, a long time ago. I have a hard time believing that any of the things "debunked" here are actually real.

alakra• 2 years ago

As someone who lives near the rocky mountains, I will say the part about getting struck by lightning by a storm that's up to 10 miles away is quite accurate.

I was out riding my bike one afternoon in Chatfield State Park in Colorado when I looked up and noticed how quickly the weather changed. Clouds had rolled over the mountains in the west and I heard lightning strike in the distance.

In the same second, I saw electricity arc between my hands and the handle bars as my fingers froze for a second. I didn't feel any pain or shock, but I got out of the area real quick.

LorenPechtel• 2 years ago

It only made sense to me if you expected an imminent strike on something nearby. Any other scenario I would think you would be better off getting off the X, or finding some bit of terrain that would make you not the highest thing around.

It also seems to be that people already understand getting off the X. Locally I'm aware of one rescue when someone got off the X and got cliffed out (no surprise given the terrain) and I'm aware of one fatality where the details were never reported but the location of his body only makes sense if he got off the X and got cliffed out--but on the other side where there's no cell service and the missing person's reports made no mention of satellite stuff. I'm not aware of any lighting deaths in the area, though. (Of course the real answer is don't go up there in lightning weather! The day he disappeared I had been considering a hike but considered the weather a no-go.)

burntwater• 2 years ago

Boy the bots are thirsty today... But anyho, most of this is actually news to me. One bit that doesn't make sense to me is how caves or rock overhangings don't provide protection. I'm not following that, if it saying that the electricity will still make it's way back into the cave floor? Does it matter if you're 3 feet from the opening or 30 feet?

random42_• 2 years ago

One bit that doesn't make sense to me is how caves or rock overhangings don't provide protection.

There is a hiking in my home state that takes about 2 days to complete. Along the way, there is a huge rock that fits that description; it sits in the middle of an open area. We are taught to never seek shelter under it when there is lightning. When asking why, we’re told that that rock is informally called “The Microwave”, because, well, exactly what the article says.

This has been common knowledge in the area for a very long time already (not sure if specific to that rock or for any cave or overhanging rock in general like the article says).

Everything Hikers Know About Lightning Safety Is Wrong

Related Stories