Ask HN: How much does an MBA help in building a business

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39907945

by gavin_ • 2 years ago

5 7 2 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

The linear path has always been described to me as "go to an elite school for undergrad, work a few years, go back to school for an MBA" and then you're set -- what is the point of this? I don't understand why I would need/want an MBA.

MakeThemMoney• 2 years ago

The MBA is not for building a business, it's for having the credentials to get a comfy management job at an established corporation.

p1esk• 2 years ago

If you don’t know why you would need it - you don’t need it.

GoldenMonkey• 2 years ago

^this

ActorNightly• 2 years ago

MBA is mainly for connections. It gets you into companies that require an MBA (solely as a signal that you are willing to play the game), which then gives you exposure to how things are done in the real world, which then lets you leverage people and networks to either rise through the company or start your own in the sense of you just being the person who directs who should do what, while getting paid to do that.

paulcole• 2 years ago

then you're set

Set for what?

BioBen42• 2 years ago

As someone who has gone from engineering grad school to law school and then got an MBA, I can't say I would recommend the MBA unless you do not have any technical skills or have no sense of direction when it comes to basic business and accounting concepts. If you can read a 10K report and get a good idea of the health of a company, then you will be more competent than many MBA graduates.

In addition, there are so many MBA programs out there that are basically scams to separate you from your money. Your MBA will only be as respected as the school is. As many of the comments allude to, the main purpose of the MBA is to network and show employers that you are ready to "play the game." Your mileage you get out of the degree (when it comes to employment) is pretty much directly proportional to the rank of the school.

However, there are some instances where an MBA makes sense. Sometimes, individuals looking for a career change or to get an internal promotion/raise will use an MBA program to pivot since it gives you two years to make a seamless transition on your resume.

If you are looking to go back to school to obtain some skills to better build your business, I would recommend going to law school over getting an MBA. From my personal experience, I would say that law school provided me with more pertinent information about running a business than my MBA. While law school is far more rigorous than an MBA program, it would certainly be worth your time if you can get the score to get into a good one. There is a reason why many successful founders have law degrees. I think it is because law classes teach you not only to think clearly but also to think about contingencies -- skills that are essential to building a business. You will also be surrounded by intelligent, hyper-driven people which creates an interesting atmosphere, to say the least.

gavin_• 2 years ago

This is great information! How do you know if a law school is a good one? For MBAs it comes down to brand recognition so it’s pretty easy to tell them apart, I think it’s more hidden for law schools. Also curious what score you need on the LSAT to get into one of those.

Ask HN: How much does an MBA help in building a business

Related Stories