Ask HN: Minimum viable product release private or public?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3237076

by fsethi • 15 years ago

7 7 15 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

Long time reader, first time poster. Do you guys think it is better to release a minimum viable product into the wild (open beta) rather than have a private beta?

skotzko• 15 years ago

Probably depends on how many people or customers you have lined up for your private beta. If it's of sufficient size, a private beta can work just as well as a public launch.

fsethi3• 15 years ago

Frankly, this is a sort of hack job @pud would be happy about it. Had an idea, busting it out in a few days and seeing what happens.

gbelote• 15 years ago

Short answer is: It depends. Why would you want to release as a private beta?

You probably want users to be able to freely refer your product to friends. You probably want people to be able to discover, sign up, and try your product in one sitting. You probably don't want potential users to lose enthusiasm while they wait for a beta invite. You probably won't have crushing server traffic. If you do, you probably won't regret letting so many people use your product at once.

fsethi3• 15 years ago

Thanks for the input. Agreed. I come from a design background so releasing something hacked together is a challenge for me. Furthermore, it really is a MVP-- there are definitely UX issues and functionality I would like to address/add, but resources are limited.

ravikalaga• 15 years ago

What could be cooler for a few days work to be out in open beta? You get feedback from real users (not friends/well wishers) and if it works well or sucks, you at least get honest feedback.

fsethi3• 15 years ago

Agreed -- tangible honest feedback from real people is invaluable. Thanks for the feedback.

smtlaissezfaire• 15 years ago

As far as I understand it, MVP is all about determining whether there might be customers out there for you. (It's answering the question "Is anyone actually going to buy this thing?").

So staying small and out of the public spotlight to iterate on failure is valuable (and doesn't produce any negative PR).

If you have to go open beta to get that feedback, then do so. If you can get away with a private beta, do so.

Here's the better question: Can you set up a system so that you don't even need any sort of beta to tell?

Ask HN: Minimum viable product release private or public?

Related Stories