Is the internet everything we hoped for?

https://robinwinslow.uk/is-the-internet-everything-we-hoped-for

by nottrobin • 4 years ago

6 2 4 years ago

ggm• 4 years ago

This has to invoke Betteridges law of headlines.

As one who had the great fortune to be part of networking in the UK in the 70s and 80s, including a stint in UCL-CS working at the end of the SATNET/ARPANET years (UCL was the uk end of the ARPAnet of the day, with an IMP, and then a BBN butterfly, and a large tranche of addresses held I believe in conjunction with the UK signals directorate of the Ministry of Defence) -I can tell you its a bit from box A and a bit from box B.

It worked better than a lot of us (X.25!) thought.

It worked a lot better than the code a lot of us were working on (the OSI/GOSIP model)

USENET was both worse and better than online communities.

The 1984 RAND report on the social behaviours in EMail remain true to this day, discussing flaming and trolling behaviours.

https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-irtf-hrpc-associ... is an indication of how important the questions have become.

Also see https://reasonablypolymorphic.com/blog/monotonous-web/index.... which is at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32348519

nottrobin• 4 years ago

Ah yes I forgot Betteridge's law. I wasn't exactly sure what the headline should be, I almost made it something more definitive. But I think what I was actually trying to do with that headline was sort of a double bluff - modern attitudes to the effects of the internet are pretty negative and cynical that I would assume everyone would immediately think the answer to that question should be "no", and so I'm trying to put forward the surprising case for it to perhaps be "yes". (While not dismissing or shying away from any of the modern criticisms, which I mostly completely agree with).

Thanks for this links, they're really interesting. They are exactly the sort of questions I'm exploring here, and I think we should all be asking.

Is the internet everything we hoped for?

Related Stories