Ask News.YC: Are you getting an iPhone?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27571

by palish • 19 years ago

5 17 19 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

kyro• 19 years ago

Eh, lack of 3g and GPS really stings. Also, I am very curious as to typing ability. I've read from several sources that typing is really cumbersome.

However, I'm a huge sucker for Apple and Apple marketing. And, the touchscreen/OS/UI look brilliant. But, for $500 with a 2 year and the required data plans, I'm not sure. I am a dirt poor college student, after all.

Palm is coming out with a new one later this year with wifi, 3g, and GPS.

schoudha• 19 years ago

Lack of GPS on the phone might not be that bad. Apple seems to be betting that WiFi is going to become more and more pervasive and as a result you can uses "GPS-Style" services through the internet, like Google Maps.

It's something I think a lot of currently generation Mobile services (i.e. Loopt) should strongly consider.

dawie• 19 years ago

I am waiting for the reviews. Also the first iPod was not that great, but by the time G2, G3 and the Mini was out it bacame an awesome product.

I will get one if I can have an all you can eat Internet plan to go with it and if the web is not too slow on it.

donna• 19 years ago

Yes, I agree. I'll be waiting until the first batch is tested by the Apple enthusiasts. However I will be getting one!

davidw• 19 years ago

Only if you're going to send me one.

jsjenkins168• 19 years ago

Not anymore.

At least not until Apple opens the iPhone as a development platform. IMHO, the exciting possibilities would come from 3rd party software, which they apparently plan to keep out. I think market pressures will eventually force them to open the doors for developers but until then no thanks.

ravi_n• 19 years ago

Not unless I can install 3rd-party, native applications.

cwilbur• 19 years ago

Depends on what the monthly plan is like.

$100 is more than I've spent on my current cell phone in the year I've had it. The iPhone would have to be really sweet to justify spending that much each month on top of its purchase price.

jward• 19 years ago

Not until they offer it in Canada ;) The contract on my current phone is up in December. The iPhone apparently starts being sold up here in January.

gibsonf12• 19 years ago

I'm going to wait until I can use it on Verizon. I really don't want any more accounts with AT&T at this point. (They absolutely screwed me recently by charging $4+ for long distance calls per minute - yikes!. I'm getting rid of my home AT&T phone (will just use cell) and getting rid of their expensive DSL, and going with Comcast cable internet - which is theoretically much faster and half the cost)

ricardo• 19 years ago

Verizon is just as bad. I can't wait to get off their wireless service. I recently moved to the SF Bay Area and found that my cell on a nationwide plan was roaming continuously. Somehow the phone I bought from them won't update its network listing so the options given to me from their reps were 1. Renew my 2 year plan and get $100 towards a new phone or 2. Buy a phone off of craigslist and pay them $20 to transfer it. I'll be glad to switch to a GSM network where I can buy phones online and swap the SIM cards if I need to.

gibsonf12• 19 years ago

Sorry to hear that. I've been using Verizon for years, and one of the main reasons was their amazing coverage all over the US. I've had great luck with them to date, especially with their coverage. I can't even remember the last time I had a coverage problem. I also have an associate using their broadband wireless card on his laptop, and he's successfully maintaining a good connection on his daily train commute from Gilroy up to SF (1.5 - 2 hour trip each way.) keeping a connection to our internal webapp via VPN.

brianmckenzie• 19 years ago

Yes, I will get an iPhone but not the day they come out. I'm going to wait for my service plan with t-mobile to expire and then make the switch...should be in early 2008. Hopefully that will be enough time 'in the wild' to evaluate if this thing is as cool as it seems to be, the status of 3rd-party apps, new calling plans, etc.

joshwa• 19 years ago

Never buy an Apple r1.0 product.

lupin_sansei• 19 years ago

"Eat up Martha" springs to mind

fuelfive• 19 years ago

Yes

keven• 19 years ago

I'm gonna start selling some AAPL stocks

Ask News.YC: Are you getting an iPhone?

Related Stories