California Bill Would Mandate 'Crime Prediction' Algorithms Instead of Cash Bail

https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/n7wymd/california-bill-would-mandate-crime-prediction-algorithms-instead-of-cash-bail

by elsewhen • 6 years ago

9 2 6 years ago

vice.com

astrophysician• 6 years ago

As a data scientist, this is terrifying. A questionnaire is asking things like "have you only held low-wage jobs" to determine if someone should be locked up? The model isn't completely open to the public? (how that is justified is beyond me, this model literally decides whether or not you, as a citizen, are locked in a box).

If it's not obvious: these methods easily reinforce all sorts of terrible biases in the data. Even with a perfectly transparent model, it's unclear what sort of data biases you are reinforcing, because getting unbiased data is extremely difficult if not impossible.

lsb• 6 years ago

This is a serious problem in many ways.

Ethics can be a distraction from justice.

Ethics sites the problem in the algorithm, whereas justice sites the problem in the power differential.

People generally trust computers more than random human decisions, and computers can automate the repercussions of their decisions quickly. If you work hourly at a government job, and you get your hours yanked when you're judged a risk, without time for an appeal, things spiral out of your control, exacerbating oppression.

California Bill Would Mandate 'Crime Prediction' Algorithms Instead of Cash Bail

Related Stories