Which ereader device should I buy?

http://www.the-digital-reader.com/2010/11/26/%E2%80%9Cwhich-ereader-device-should-i-buy%E2%80%9D/

by _b8r0 • 16 years ago

13 16 16 years ago

burgerbrain2• 16 years ago

[Posting from my Kindle 3] buy a kindle! ;)

marcc• 16 years ago

There are no scenarios where he recommends the E Ink Nook. Strange. It's actually a decent device, but is there really no room for it in the market?

burgerbrain2• 16 years ago

He recommends the "Nook" (not Nook color) in two cases:

>I want to be able to read ebooks that I check out from my local library: Nook or Sony Reader Daily Edition PRS-950

>I want to be able to go online and check email, use Wikipedia, read news, etc. on my device: Kindle or Nook

He seems to prefer the kindle to the nook however because ebooks are apparently cheaper on average, it has a newer eink display, the wifi version is cheaper, and it's easier to use (whatever that means...).

funksta4• 16 years ago

Still waiting for an ereader with a screen > 9" and good PDF support. The Kindle DX is oh-so-close, but it doesn't support PDF table of contents or annotations. A touch screen would also be nice. Anyone aware of any other products that meet these criteria?

dagw• 16 years ago

Notion ink Adam is really the only thing on the horizon. Since it runs android you can use any android pdf reader and since it has a pixelQi screen it should have decent battery life and a nice readable screen.

Only downside is it's not actually available yet. Pre-orders should be starting soon though.

funksta4• 16 years ago

The Adam looks like it has some serious potential. Not sure how the Pixel Qi screens will compare to eInk for reading though.

mickdarling2• 16 years ago

I have an Entourage Edge and it does have a nice big screen, I I know it supports PDF's I use them all the time. Not positive about table of contents support, but I can try that out in a bit.

It does have a lot of issues though. It has two screens, one e-ink, and one LCD. It uses Android 1.6 right now and has no access to the Android Market. The company that makes it has minimal resources and they are really not supportive of developers. The LCD screen is resistive touch and its responsiveness isn't great. You can get a very long time on a charge if you make sure to turn the LCD off while you are reading.It isn't the worlds greatest e-reader, but it might suit your requirements where nothing else does.

funksta4• 16 years ago

Interesting, thanks for the heads up. I'm going to wait for a device with a single, big screen though.

cletus• 16 years ago

It's called an "iPad". I know it's not an e-ink device but, for reading any tech book (or, in fact, anything nonsequential), the iPad (with Goodreader) is WAY better.

funksta4• 16 years ago

I would love it if the iPad met my needs, but I find extended reading difficult on backlit LCDs.

rosejn• 16 years ago

I was pretty happy with my cybook before leaving it on an airplane. Don't go Kindle, unless you want to support them after dropping WikiLeaks, thus taking the freedom of the press and flushing it down the toilet.

russell_h2• 16 years ago

I've got no beef with Wikileaks, but how do you construe the actions of a private company as "taking the freedom of the press and flushing it down the toilet"?

zdw• 16 years ago

Reading linear books (novels, etc.), get an e-ink reader like the Kindle, etc. You won't mind the page delay if it's one page at a time.

Reading tech books (manuals, reference material, etc.) get an iPad or subnotebook. Much faster to flip rapidly through as there's a much smaller page load delay, better search etc.

I'm so thankful for ebooks - there's a line in one of the perl docs that says "You can't grep dead trees", which has always been my beef with paper docs.

yannickt• 16 years ago

Has anyone here tried the Kobo ereader? Could you share your impressions?

russell_h2• 16 years ago

My girlfriend got me a Kindle 3 as an early Christmas gift, and while there are a lot of things I wish it would do better (or at all), I actually really like it.

From worst to best:

1. The Kindle is pretty terrible for textbooks or other things used purely as references (some people supposedly read texbooks, I don't).

2. The Kindle isn't too bad for technical books that you actually want to read, but aren't going to use as references. For example I bought the Kindle version of Douglas Crockford's Javascript: the Good Parts and read it front to back without much issue. Code formatting was my greatest concern, but its not too bad. Sometimes when a code block flows between pages and you want to flip back and forth it can be a little annoying, but overall not much worse than having to turn a physical page back and forth. It can also display PDFs, which I used to read Robert Love's book about Linux Systems Programming. The PDF display functionality isn't the best, largely because it can't re-flow text to make things a good size. But as long as this isn't the main reason you want the Kindle, its not that big a deal.

3. The Kindle really comes into its own for books of pure text you just want to read front to back. My biggest gripe is that a lot of books in the Kindle store seem to have been scanned in with pretty terrible OCR (some books are perfect, but in others its comment for a '1' to be used in place of an '1' or 'i', or for some reason for 'F' to be used in place of 'I'). Since I've been in College I haven't really done much recreational reading, but the Kindle has really gotten me back into it. Since I received it about 10 days ago I've read a Tom Clancy book, 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, Javascript: The Good Parts, Red Planet and the Robert Love Systems Programming book (the name escapes me at the moment).

The real value of the Kindle (or really any e-reader, the Kindle just happened to be really cheap and reputable) to me is the instant delivery of books. When I want to read something, as long as I have Wifi (didn't get the Whisper-Net-whatever-version) I can find something to read. Even better, Project Gutenberg has a huge collection of free Kindle-formatted ebooks. I can't normally be bothered to go to a store to pick up a book, or even wait for one to be delivered, and I don't like reading off of a computer or phone. But when I can instantly have a book on a great screen, and even have a huge selection of free ones, suddenly I find that I can't stop reading.

Which ereader device should I buy?

Related Stories