Ask HN: How to plan the optimal route for a moving van?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1785802
by newobj • 16 years ago
3 1 16 years ago

This might be a bit weird for HN, but I thought it posed a good hacker challenge :)

I'm moving from Phoenix, AZ to Seattle, WA next week. I'm driving my own 24' moving van (with car in-tow).

I'm trying to figure out what the optimal route is for this van. I want to minimize elevation changes, exposure to inclement weather, and overall driving pressure (e.g. narrow/fewer lanes, road curvature, etc).

There are the 3 primary routes one could take to make this trip:

1. I-5. (via Los Angeles) (http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=en&geocode=Fblh_gEdy-JR-SnLeaFQ7RIrhzGsG0o1-MdpjA%3BFX77WwIdaji3-CnBgh2LcQODgDEp8DhLJVAWYw%3BFcJp1gIdWVy1-ClVM-iTLBCQVDGa1URpRmUlEA&q=phoenix,+az+to+seattle,+wa&sll=40.446947,-117.246094&sspn=20.730412,46.538086&ie=UTF8&ll=40.513799,-117.202148&spn=20.710218,46.538086&t=h&z=5&saddr=phoenix,+az&daddr=39.5825903,-122.210198+to:seattle,+wa&via=1) I've done this drive at least half a dozen times (in a car). Things are fine (if boring) until Northern California and Oregon, when you really start to get into a lot of elevation changes. And in northern Oregon (Portland area), I inevitably seem to get caught in a combo of rain + chewed up highway that I don't think I'd like to navigate very much in a 24' truck with car in tow.

2. I-84. (via Salt Lake City) (http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=en&geocode=Fblh_gEdy-JR-SnLeaFQ7RIrhzGsG0o1-MdpjA%3BFcm_bQId53NU-Skb8Pps3_RShzG650FYs2ragw%3BFcJp1gIdWVy1-ClVM-iTLBCQVDGa1URpRmUlEA&q=phoenix,+az+to+seattle,+wa&sll=37.0625,-95.677068&sspn=43.037246,93.076172&ie=UTF8&ll=40.446947,-117.246094&spn=20.730412,46.538086&t=h&z=5&saddr=phoenix,+az&daddr=40.7469536,-111.9058178+to:seattle,+wa&via=1) I've done this drive once in a car in the opposite direction. It felt flatter than drive #1, but you'd never know it judging by the terrain the route takes you over. So maybe it was my imagination?

3. US-93 and I-84 (via Las Vegas) (http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=en&geocode=Fblh_gEdy-JR-SnLeaFQ7RIrhzGsG0o1-MdpjA%3BFcJp1gIdWVy1-ClVM-iTLBCQVDGa1URpRmUlEA&q=phoenix,+az+to+seattle,+wa&sll=40.513799,-117.202148&sspn=20.710218,46.538086&ie=UTF8&t=h&z=5&saddr=phoenix,+az&daddr=seattle,+wa) Never done this route before. It's the default suggested Google route.

So does anyone have any heuristics or insight into what the best route for this 24' truck would be?

Related Stories

Loading related stories...

Source preview

news.ycombinator.com