Wisconsin Sucks for Startups

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=168350

by snagwag12 • 18 years ago

6 17 18 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

It is damn near impossible to start a startup outside a 'startup hub', but I'm going to attempt the impossible this summer. Around here, mentioning to friends that I'm going to do a startup usually entails a detailed description of a new landscaping business. Software and technology are completely oblivious in the minds of my fellow Wisconinites. Software development and website design lays in the hands of the few professional web firms at a very steep price. I was quoted a total of $30,000 to create the type of website I want. It doesn't include any innovative software programming. The site is by no means a simple task, but in no way is it too difficult for an experienced firm.

My question to you guys is whether or not it is worth it. I've read all the blogs and am constantly up to date on YC news. The trends suggest that there is a high demand for it, but the risk is quite significant. I have no co-founder and I expect to graduate college by next May. I'm just a kid chasing clouds. Is the risk worth the reward??

projectileboy• 18 years ago

Given that you're about to be freshly-minted college grad, it seems to me the worst thing that can happen is that one year from now you'll have a little credit card debt, with a year's experience worth ten times that which you'd get at American Conglomerated Megacorp.

I assume you're in Madison. If so, there are good hackers to be found (Raven Software, for one). Connect with them, if only for moral support.

9oliYQjP• 18 years ago

Have you fully quantified the risk and the reward? If not, that's your first priority. Here is some food for thought:

1. If you farm out your website, there is a significant risk that you will spend some or all of the $30K and it will not come out the way you want or even be useable. Ensure you go with a reputable firm with a portfolio of sites that you can actually check out yourself. This is not the time to farm out an idea to a freelance programmer no matter how good s/he is. Just trust me on this (I was once of those freelance programmers!).

2. If things turn out not so bleak from having outsourced the work, chances are that it will be over budget and late. So ensure you have contingency plans (e.g., maybe it will take 1 year instead of 4 months, and $60K instead of $30K to get done).

3. If you aren't in a startup hub, and you aren't in a program like startup school, then your support system is going to be essentially non-existent. This is a very very bad thing. I tried to start a business right out of school in such a situation (and with the tech economy in the gutter) and let me tell you it was very difficult. I got a salaried job for a few years to re-group and am back on my own two feet. You will want to seek out lots of mentors (not online, I mean people you can phone up, have meals with to chat, etc.) and do lots of networking. And even then it might not be enough. One of the great things about being in a place where there's lots of business going on is that you can't go very far without randomly bumping into folks that you might be able to help. For instance, I did a presentation last Friday and afterward two great things happened:

i) A gentleman introduced himself as somebody who worked for the investment arm of the biggest bank in Canada and asked me if I'd be interested in partnering on a project with them. Just right out of the blue. I didn't have to do anything and in fact wasn't even shopping my company around. I was just there to present the results of a project we did for a client.

ii) One of the directors on the board of my client company spoke about a PR campaign that he was initiating and I soon realized that another company that I've worked with would be an amazing fit for him to partner with. Afterwards, I approached him, told him about that company, we exchanged cards and he asked me to email him with the details.

Basically, this sort of thing is bound to happen a lot less frequently in smaller communities (in both overall population and in terms of industry size). You would be surprised how much businesses rely on luck. Luck really is the intersection where preparedness meets opportunity. If you're in a big city that has a lot of folks doing what you're doing, then a lot of times opportunities just randomly present themselves like they did last Friday for me (and my friends at that other company). It's just statistics.

mynameishere• 18 years ago

I was quoted a total of $30,000 to create the type of website I want.

That's odd----all the websites I've owned costs zero. Oh, right, I made them myself.

johnm3• 18 years ago

Well, to play devil's advocate (since I gave the same advice :-)...

No, those sites still cost you in terms of your time both directly and in terms of opportunity cost.

Particularly in startups, one must always be asking: WITMVTICBDRN. :-)

snagwag123• 18 years ago

Thanks to everyone for their advice!! The reason I'm not designing it myself is because I'm not a CS major. I am majoring in marketing with a minor in economics. My job in this whole mess is to market, advertise, organize, and implement. If I could just get the technical stuff worked out (even at a bloated price), I think it'd be worth it. My mindset is... what's the worst that could happen? If I blow it, I'll have one hell of a story to tell at job interviews.

freikwcs• 18 years ago

You add so much value.

rman666• 18 years ago

$30K is too much. It will be too painful a lesson if does not pan out. There are less expensive options. I suggest you contact some of the people involved in setting up BarCamp Milwaukee 1 & 3, Web414, and maybe Silicon Pastures. (Google them). There is not a lot of support for entrepreneurs in Wisconsin. The city and state will tell you there is, but that's a lot of talk. The best options for support (emotional, ideas, financial, etc.) come from grass roots sources, at least here.

snagwag123• 18 years ago

Thanks for the recommendations. I'll be sure to check them out.

enra• 18 years ago

Professional web firms' prices are high everywhere. Since you're new to website business(?) they could even try to shut you off by setting the price even higher. That way they wouldn't need to actually implement your custom build site. And if you would take the offer they would atleast get some nice profits.

I work in this business as a employee of a professional web firm and a freelancer. I have come across a lot of clients that think they know what they want but actually don't. You should know that when you want something custom build, its going to cost you, by the hour and more.

1. Write clear specs. If you know software development you should know how to write clear specs. Try to drop features that are not important. There is a lots of stuff that could go wrong, besides the site, so could it work with less features?

2. Freelance designers are actually good. Find one that you like and provide the layout for the web firm, so the firm will only do the technical side and you will probably save some bucks.

3. Do as much as you can by yourself. Draw the basic structure of a site in powerpoint/gimp or whatever. Just some boxes that show eg. where is navigation, header, news, some featured products etc. Draw all the different pages and try to write or draw how the site should work.

4. You don't need to use a Wisconsian web firm. It's not like there is lots of shipping involved. If you want to discuss the deal in person, a cost of few airline tickets probably isn't too much if you can get better deal.

plinkplonk• 18 years ago

Is there a reason you aren't buiding the web site yourself? If you are not a developer what is the value you bring to the proposed startup? ( I am NOT being sarcastic. This is an honest question)

johnm3• 18 years ago

Bah! Of course you an start up a web startup anywhere.

The issues comes with whether or not you need any of the advantages that come with being in/near one of the hubs that typically require in-person access such as 'smart money' investors, offices where lots of localized talent can work together, etc.

As to your website development consternation... why aren't you building the first versions of it yourself?

In terms of your schooling... is there some reason why you cannot start working on this yourself until you graduate and then go full bore if it still makes sense?

tstegart• 18 years ago

I disagree that that Wisconsin is a horrible place for start-ups. Madison is pretty big on entrepreneurship. If you go to school there, check out the entrepreneurship association at the business school. The faculty is also amazing, and they're happy to chat with you even if you're not a business student. I think if you're not finding support, you're not looking in the right place.

shellab• 18 years ago

Hey, I'm the organizer of the Madison Php group. We should get together to talk about your project, I might be able to hook you up with some developers. http://php.meetup.com/125

snagwag123• 18 years ago

whats your email address?

coffeecoffee• 18 years ago

I'm a programmer in Madison and would be willing to talk to you. email address is listed on my profile.

This website might be of interest if you haven't seen it: http://www.ocr.wisc.edu/entrep/

maxharris• 18 years ago

I live in Madison, and I did a startup here (with two co-founders) back in '99. I ended up paying ~$20k (my share of the debt, with interest) on an idea that went nowhere (and we developed our own software - it would have been much, much more expensive if we tried to pay someone else to do it).

So don't pay to do it! Your idea is most likely not right anyway. Do you really want to erase $30k to make it obvious?

If you really think you have a great idea, do this as a summer project (learn to program if you need to). Just don't borrow or spend much money on it. If people might eventually pay to use your thing, it won't matter that your implementation is rough at first.

Wisconsin Sucks for Startups

Related Stories