Ask HN: Missing FCC comments?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14770503

by godelski • 9 years ago

21 8 9 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I'm trying to figure out if anyone else's FCC comments weren't posted. I had posted one a few months back and could not find it through[1]. So I posted another one two days ago and have still not found it. I can find some of my friends, but not others. First I posted was through Battle for the net[2] and the second was through the EFF[3].

My comment through BFTN did go to my representatives, who did email me back.

Anyone else failed to find their comment?

[1] https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/

[2] https://www.battleforthenet.com/

[3] https://dearfcc.org/

lgierth• 9 years ago

Apparantly FCC had to throttle their commenting system.

IMPORTANT NOTE: these numbers STILL represent only a portion of the final totals, and due to the massive numbers, comments and emails will be delivered over several days.

https://www.fightforthefuture.org/news/2017-07-13-update-his...

godelski2• 9 years ago

I think the strange part about it, though, is the one that I posted a few months back isn't there. But thank you for this notice.

csinchok• 9 years ago

The best thing is to post your comment directly on the FCC's website. Downtime/batch posting of comments can mean that your comment could show up late, or maybe not at all.

infogulch• 9 years ago

I submitted directly via the FCC website and it was posted the day after I submitted it.

I would assume posting directly via the FCC is more reliable and also carries more weight than submitting a filled out template via an api. (If they can tell the difference.)

yebyen2• 9 years ago

I had this happen too, my experience is the same as the other posters when I used comcastroturf to post a comment. There was no sign the FCC received it at all.

If you submit your comment directly to the FCC, you get a confirmation e-mail, you don't get signed up for any mailing list (comcastroturf tried to sign me up for a mailing list), and you will see it posted to the site after a day or so passes, when they have reviewed it.

It's very interesting that so many robo-comments in support of Axe'ing the Title II laws were posted to the site, if they are being manually reviewed by someone... it's almost as if the FCC already knows what direction they're going to take, and this comment period is just a dog and pony show so they can say they had one.

godelski2• 9 years ago

Thanks, filing directly gives me a confirmation email. Hopefully I see that comment post in the next few (working) days.

yebyen2• 9 years ago

Mine only took a day to get posted, I think they must be reviewing them very carefully... /s

mkstowegnv• 9 years ago

This is slightly off topic but because of this story I went looking for my FCC comments [1] and decided to search for all recent (last week) comments from my small-population, somewhat-limited-ethnicity zip code, and discovered hundreds of anti-neutrality comments with very unlikely surnames. Every one of the ten I sampled failed a zabasearch.com search and looking in the property appraiser's website different owners are listed for the addresses given. Apparently fake comments continue to be common e.g. [2]. [1]https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/ [2]https://www.forbes.com/sites/tonybradley/2017/05/26/victims-...

Ask HN: Missing FCC comments?

Related Stories