The Aftermath of a Successful Article

http://ericharrison.info/2010/04/30/the-aftermath-of-a-successful-article/

by blister • 16 years ago

14 3 16 years ago

blister2• 16 years ago

Hopefully some of the changes I've made to my server will help the site stay up this time... ;)

> From my external perspective, it looks like all he ever does is interact with the CodeIgniter API and only begrudgingly stoops to writing regular old PHP when he needs to interact with some crazy business logic. The problem here (and the inspiration for my original article) is that there’s no transfer of skills in his development process if he is ever forced to work on a project and ordered to use CakePHP, Symphony, Zend or any one of the bazillions of PHP frameworks.

When I read this, I hear

> From my external perspective, it looks like all he ever does is interact with the PHP API and only begrudgingly stoops to writing regular old C when he needs to interact with some crazy business logic. The problem here (and the inspiration for my original article) is that there’s no transfer of skills in his development process if he is ever forced to work on a project and ordered to use Ruby, Python, APL or any one of the bazillions of PHP frameworks.

Abstractions are one of the most fundamental and useful concepts in computer science. The author realizes this, he's built up his own abstractions! Decrying other abstractions doesn't make much sense.

blister2• 16 years ago

I'm not decrying abstractions. I am the biggest proponent of abstractions on the planet.

What I disagree with is the tendency to use the same monstrous framework for every project, regardless of size, scope, and purpose.

And part of my complaint is that the abstractions don't always abstract anything. Some of them just rename things for the sake of style. That may or may not be a bad thing, but I don't think the average developer even gives this any consideration. If anything, the fact that you're passionate enough to actually leave a comment about the article generally points to the fact that you're not one of the people that needs to hear this sort of lesson. :D

The Aftermath of a Successful Article

Related Stories