Ask HN: What is the license of comments here?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10218707

by rsy96 • 11 years ago

9 9 11 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

On a site like stackoverflow, all questions and answers are licensed under Creative Commons and can be copied at will (when properly attributed). So, what is the license of comments here?

adultSwim• 11 years ago

I would assume users retain full rights to their comments. I wasn't aware I had agreed to anything else.

JoeAltmaier2• 11 years ago

No attempt to protect a copyright means no rights.

nness• 11 years ago

That is incorrect. You are thinking of trademarks and patents.

eric_bullington• 11 years ago

Nope, you're thinking of trademarks. Your copyright exists at the exact moment you create a copyrighted work, and you needn't do anything else to retain that right [1].

1. http://web.law.columbia.edu/keep-your-copyrights/copyrights

brudgers• 11 years ago

[IANAL] Not in the United States. Here copyright is owned by the author upon publication with only narrow and explicit exceptions.

eli• 11 years ago

Presumably each comment is copyrighted by its individual author and all rights are reserved unless they tell you differently. Sites like SO that explicitly require comments to be licensed CC are the exception.

maddayou• 11 years ago

Hi, I am one of those who use; parts of sentences, sentences, topics thoughts, of HN comments/commenters, from the web generaly, but i never asked. Often it's the provoking, or funy, or.... -stuff, i use. Everytime i finished something "postable" i share it with a cc-nc-share alike-licence, which i think is in the motto of educate, enlightenment, and "share". i hope that i did nothing wrong or intolerable...

it is a direct linking and dev-art doesn't like but risk a look find something dau-related here: http://orig11.deviantart.net/c302/f/2015/257/1/4/_en__by_imm...

Ask HN: What is the license of comments here?

Related Stories