Ask HN: Is it possible to be a good programmer?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10164339

by svanderbleek • 11 years ago

3 10 11 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I think given the nature of programming as it stands it is not. It is possible to be good at thinking computationally, but when it comes to platform specific implementation details and changing requirements not much can be done.

imauld• 11 years ago

I admire your courage to basically call everyone on this site a bad programmer ;-).

I also disagree with you. Why do you think nothing can be done about changing requirements? I also don't see how a client/boss changing requirements makes me a bad programmer. This is in same line of thinking as saying someone is bad at sports because sometimes it rains when they go to the park to play.

AS for platform specific implementations details there are people who have built entire careers around being experts in platform specifics.

dagw• 11 years ago

I also don't see how a client/boss changing requirements makes me a bad programmer.

Being able to take vague and changing requirements in your stride and still deliver something that the end user actually wants (as opposed to what the end user asked for/thinks they wants), is the hallmark of a great programmer. The more I work as a programmer the more I realize that simply typing code is just a small part of my job (and the easiest part).

This is in same line of thinking as saying someone is bad at sports because sometimes it rains when they go to the park to play.

It's more like a player complaining that the reasons they suck is that all their teammates can never pass the ball right. Everybody can catch/score off of a prefect pass, what makes someone great is managing to adapt to and deal with a bad pass.

lucozade• 11 years ago

If by good programmer you mean someone who produces code to some notionally optimal level in a real world environment then, sure, that's close to impossible.

If you mean someone who knows everything about every facet of computing then that ships probably sailed too.

If you mean someone who delivers software that changes the way people live and work in meaningful ways then it's most definitely possible as I see the evidence every day.

informatimago• 11 years ago

Fast, Good or Cheap. Pick Two.

Guess which two corporations want?

bbcbasic• 11 years ago

FastGood & Cheap?

J_Darnley• 11 years ago

Ah, FastGood(TM). A quality brand if ever I saw one.

MalcolmDiggs• 11 years ago

I've never been in a situation where programming was an "end" in and of itself. It has always (for me) been a means to an end.

So, I think: yes, it's definitely possible to be a good programmer. If your work-activity furthers the larger goals that you're working towards (in an effective and efficient way), then you're pretty good in my book.

ACV001• 11 years ago

We need to define the term "good programmer". Then we need to find a way to measure it and only then we can try to answer your question.

0xdeadbeefbabe• 11 years ago

Yes, but only to the degree it is possible to be an evil programmer.

dragonwriter• 11 years ago

It is possible to be good at thinking computationally, but when it comes to platform specific implementation details and changing requirements not much can be done.

Its quite possible to be an expert at platform specific implementation details for various platforms, or to be good at analyzing new platforms and understanding those details, so that part is something one can be good at, or not, too.

Its also possible to be better or worse at designing software to be maintainable in the face of evolving requirements.

Ask HN: Is it possible to be a good programmer?

Related Stories